Imagine a world where your deepest personal convictions, your most profound beliefs about morality and purpose, suddenly become not just a guide for your own life, but a rigid blueprint for everyone else’s. A world where your faith, however sincere, grants you the authority to dictate who others can marry, what healthcare choices they can make, or even how they express their inherent identity. This isn’t a dystopian fantasy; it’s the very real threat posed when the fundamental right to “freedom of religion” is dangerously misinterpreted and weaponized as a tool for control.
This is a topic that ignites a deep, persistent frustration within me. I frequently encounter the argument that deeply conservative, often religiously motivated, policies against LGBTQ+ rights, reproductive freedom, or inclusive education are simply expressions of “religious freedom.” But I’m here to articulate why that interpretation is a fundamental distortion of one of our nation’s most cherished liberties, and why it poses a direct threat to the very fabric of a pluralistic society.
Defining True Religious Freedom: A Shield, Not a Sword
Let’s begin with clarity. In a liberal democracy, true freedom of religion is a shield, not a sword. It is the invaluable protection that guarantees every individual the right to believe (or not to believe) as their conscience dictates, and to practice their faith (or lack thereof) free from government coercion or interference. It means the government cannot establish a national religion, nor can it prohibit the free exercise of individual faith. This foundational principle, enshrined in the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, was deliberately designed to protect religious minorities from the tyranny of a religious majority, preventing the kind of religious persecution that fueled emigration from Europe.
This protection is absolute for individual belief and private practice. You are free to worship, to preach within your congregation, to raise your children according to your faith, and to live your personal life guided by your spiritual convictions. This is a profound and essential liberty that must be vigorously defended for all.
However, where the misinterpretation begins, and the danger arises, is when this freedom is twisted into a right to impose one’s religious beliefs on others, particularly through state law or public policy. Freedom of religion does not grant anyone the right to discriminate, to inflict harm, or to deny fundamental rights to individuals who do not share their particular faith or moral code.
The Weaponization of Faith: When Freedom Becomes Control
The alarming trend we’re witnessing today is the active weaponization of “religious freedom” by certain factions to justify policies that, fundamentally, seek to control the lives of others. This is where the tension becomes acute and the stakes become terrifyingly high:
-
To Justify Discrimination: This is perhaps the most direct and painful manifestation. We see instances where individuals or businesses claim a “religious exemption” to refuse services to LGBTQ+ individuals, interfaith couples, or others they disapprove of. This attempts to redefine religious freedom as a right to discriminate. But my right to marry my partner, or a person’s right to access a public service, should not be contingent upon another individual’s religious beliefs. True freedom protects my belief, not my right to impose my belief on your actions.
-
To Control Bodily Autonomy: The relentless assault on reproductive rights, particularly the implementation of abortion bans across numerous states, is almost exclusively driven by specific religious doctrines. When the state dictates what healthcare choices an individual can make regarding their own body, citing a particular religious belief about the beginning of life, that is not protecting religious freedom; it is imposing a singular religious viewpoint on a diverse population, including those who hold different faiths or no faith at all. My body is not a canvas for your scripture.
-
To Impose Morality on Public Life: This often targets the LGBTQ+ community directly. Advocates claim “religious freedom” to justify laws that restrict drag performances, ban gender-affirming care for adults and children (despite overwhelming medical consensus), prevent gay couples from adopting, or undermine marriage equality. These actions seek to impose a narrow, religiously defined morality onto an entire, pluralistic society, rather than simply living by that morality themselves. My very existence, my identity, and my relationships are treated as a threat to someone else’s belief system, when my life impacts them in no way.
-
To Censor Education and Public Discourse: Under the guise of protecting religious values, there’s a growing movement to ban books, restrict curriculum, and even limit discussion of LGBTQ+ issues or critical race theory in schools and public libraries. This is an attempt to impose a particular worldview and shield children from ideas that might challenge parental religious beliefs, rather than trusting families to guide their own children’s education and exposure. It undermines intellectual freedom and the foundational principles of a robust, diverse education system.
The Devastating Impact: My Personal Lived Reality
As a gay man who experienced the profound trauma of being outed and sent to a “pray the gay away” camp, and who has lived in a politically and religiously conservative state like Texas, this perversion of religious freedom is not an abstract concept; it’s a lived, painful reality. My early life was directly harmed by individuals and institutions who believed their religious freedom gave them the right to deny my existence, to “cure” me, and ultimately, to abandon me. That experience taught me that when religious belief morphs into a tool for control, it generates immense suffering.
My career as an RN, witnessing the dire consequences of limited healthcare access and systemic discrimination, only solidified this conviction. When medical decisions are dictated by religious ideology rather than patient well-being, the human cost is immeasurable. When one group’s beliefs are enshrined in law to the detriment of another’s rights, it creates an atmosphere of fear and inequality for everyone who doesn’t conform.
The Danger to Pluralism and Democracy
This dangerous reinterpretation of religious freedom threatens the very essence of a pluralistic democracy. A healthy society thrives on diversity of thought, belief, and lifestyle. When one group attempts to impose its religious doctrines through civil law, it:
-
Undermines Individual Liberty: It erodes the fundamental right of individuals to live authentically, make personal choices, and pursue happiness free from state-sanctioned religious coercion.
-
Creates a Hierarchy of Rights: It implies that some people’s religious freedoms are more important than others’ basic human rights, creating a two-tiered system of citizenship.
-
Fosters Intolerance: It legitimizes prejudice and provides a convenient excuse for bigotry, allowing discrimination to hide behind a shield of “sincerely held beliefs.”
-
Threatens Social Cohesion: When a society is fractured by groups attempting to control one another based on religious doctrine, it undermines trust, exacerbates division, and erodes the common ground necessary for collective progress.
The Founding Fathers understood this danger. They established a separation of church and state precisely to protect religious freedom for all, not to enable religious dominance over others. Their wisdom, born from observing centuries of religious wars and persecution, is as relevant today as it was then.
A Call for True Liberty: Respect, Not Control
So, what is the path forward? It’s about rigorously upholding the true meaning of religious freedom: absolute liberty of belief and practice for every individual, but absolutely no right to impose those beliefs on others through the force of law.
We must:
-
Defend True Religious Freedom: Protect the right of all faiths and non-faiths to thrive.
-
Reject Discrimination: Unequivocally reject any attempt to use religious freedom as a license to discriminate against LGBTQ+ individuals, women, racial minorities, or any other group.
-
Uphold Separation of Church and State: Insist that civil law is based on secular principles that protect the rights of all citizens, not just those of a particular faith.
-
Advocate for Inclusive Laws: Push for comprehensive non-discrimination protections and policies that affirm the dignity and rights of every individual.
Freedom of religion is a beautiful thing. It allows each person to find their own spiritual path, to live according to their conscience, and to build communities of shared belief. But it has never, and should never, mean the freedom to control, dictate, or diminish the lives of others. That is not liberty; that is oppression, disguised in the vestments of faith. Let’s call it out for what it is and fight for a society where true freedom, for all, is the guiding principle.