The world of reality competition television is vast, often dominated by the familiar titans—the long-running sagas of Survivor, the cutthroat kitchens of Top Chef, or the glamorous runways of Drag Race. While these giants undeniably deliver consistent entertainment and strategic brilliance, their immense popularity often casts a long shadow, obscuring a constellation of equally compelling, yet tragically overlooked, gems. Today, my internal compass points to these hidden treasures: The Most Underrated Reality Competition Shows You’re Not Watching (But Should Be).
As someone deeply drawn to the raw human drama, intricate challenges, and strategic depths of competitive reality (a genre I consider the ultimate nerd sport), I’ve spent countless hours sifting through the digital landscape, always searching for that next addictive experience. And what I’ve found are shows that, despite their lower profile, consistently deliver high-stakes competition, profound human stories, and a level of artistry that demands wider recognition. It’s time to pull these brilliant, often unheralded, series into the light.
The Allure of the Unseen: Why These Shows Deserve Your Attention
These underrated competition shows offer a refreshing counterpoint to the often-formulaic nature of mainstream reality television. They distinguish themselves through unique premises, a genuine focus on skill and artistry, and often, a more authentic portrayal of the human spirit under pressure.
- Elevating Niche Crafts: Many of these shows shine a spotlight on highly specialized, often mesmerizing, crafts that are rarely seen on television. They transform intricate artistic processes—from glassblowing to makeup artistry—into compelling, accessible competitions.
- Authentic Passion: The contestants often bring a palpable level of passion and dedication to their craft, making their journeys incredibly compelling. You witness genuine artistic struggle, creative breakthroughs, and the profound satisfaction of mastery.
- Less Manufactured Drama: While reality TV inherently involves some degree of engineered conflict, many of these underrated gems focus more on the competition itself, the creative process, and the personal growth of the contestants, rather than manufactured interpersonal drama or contrived twists. The true tension comes from the challenge, not petty squabbles.
- Fresh Perspectives: They offer unique cultural insights and diverse perspectives, often featuring international contestants or exploring artistic traditions from around the world.
It’s time to broaden your viewing horizons and discover the rich rewards these unheralded shows have to offer.
My Top Picks for Underrated Excellence:
Here are a few of my personal favorites, shows that I believe consistently deliver a high level of entertainment, artistry, and genuine competitive spirit, and that you should absolutely add to your watchlist:
-
Glow Up: Britain’s Next Make-Up Star (BBC/Netflix)
- What it is: This British reality competition series challenges aspiring makeup artists to push their creative boundaries through a series of increasingly elaborate and demanding themed assignments. From prosthetic work for film sets and high-fashion editorial looks to fantastical body painting and intricate character transformations, the artists are pushed to their limits.
- Why it’s great: It’s utterly mesmerizing. The level of artistry, skill, and sheer creativity on display is breathtaking. You see makeup not just as a beauty tool, but as a genuine art form capable of incredible transformations. The judges are experts who provide insightful, specific critiques, and the competition is fierce but generally supportive. It’s a fantastic insight into a highly specialized craft, constantly demonstrating the power of visual storytelling and artistic innovation. The contestants’ passion is palpable, and the final reveals are always stunning.
- Perfect for fans of: Face Off, Project Runway, and anyone who appreciates visual artistry and meticulous craftsmanship.
-
Blown Away (Netflix)
- What it is: This Canadian competition series takes viewers into the thrilling, often dangerous, world of glassblowing. Talented glass artists compete in a “hot shop,” creating intricate and monumental glass sculptures within tight time limits, constantly battling the unforgiving nature of molten glass, immense heat, and the ticking clock.
- Why it’s great: It’s visually stunning and incredibly educational. The process of glassblowing is mesmerizing—watching raw molten glass transform into delicate, complex art is a true spectacle. The stakes feel incredibly high because one wrong move can shatter hours of work, literally. The artists are immensely talented and passionate, and their personal stories add depth. The judges (especially resident expert Katherine Gray) provide excellent technical and artistic insights. It’s a compelling blend of artistry, engineering, and high-stakes drama that consistently delivers breathtaking results and heartbreaking failures.
- Perfect for fans of: Great British Bake Off (for the focus on craft), Forged in Fire (for the hot, dangerous materials), and anyone fascinated by extreme artistry.
-
Making the Cut (Amazon Prime Video)
- What it is: Hosted by Heidi Klum and Tim Gunn (reuniting after Project Runway), Making the Cut takes established fashion designers from around the world and challenges them to create commercial yet innovative collections under immense pressure. The winning looks are immediately available for purchase on Amazon, blurring the lines between competition and real-world commerce.
- Why it’s great: It’s Project Runway grown up and gone global. The designers are often more experienced, the budgets are larger, and the stakes feel genuinely higher due to the immediate retail component. It offers a more sophisticated look at the business of fashion, beyond just the runway. Heidi and Tim’s chemistry is as charming as ever, and the global cast brings diverse cultural perspectives to their designs. It’s a fascinating look at the intersection of creativity, commerce, and global trends.
- Perfect for fans of: Project Runway, Next in Fashion, and anyone interested in the business and artistry of the fashion world.
-
The Circle Brazil (Netflix)
- What it is: A Brazilian installment of The Circle franchise, where contestants communicate solely through a unique social media app, building profiles and forming connections without ever meeting face-to-face. They compete for popularity and a cash prize, and players can choose to be themselves or “catfish” (impersonate someone else).
- Why it’s great: While The Circle US is popular, the Brazilian version (and often the French version) brings an extra layer of unique cultural dynamics, strategic cunning, and emotional depth. The language barrier (with subtitles) adds a fascinating element, and the players often approach the social game with different levels of emotional vulnerability and strategic manipulation. It’s a compelling sociological experiment, highlighting how identity, perception, and communication play out in a digital space. The catfishing plots are often brilliantly executed, and the genuine friendships that form are truly heartwarming. It’s a masterclass in social chess within a digital cage.
- Perfect for fans of: The Circle US, Big Brother, and anyone fascinated by social experiments, strategy, and the complexities of online identity.
These underrated gems prove that the world of reality competition is far more expansive and innovative than the mainstream often suggests. They offer a refreshing blend of genuine talent, compelling human stories, and high-stakes competition, providing a consistent stream of captivating entertainment that deserves a wider audience. So, the next time you’re looking for something new to watch, step beyond the familiar titans and unearth one of these hidden jewels. You might just find your next obsession.
What are your favorite underrated reality competition shows? What aspects of these shows do you find most compelling? Share your thoughts below – let’s discuss the vibrant world of unheralded talent!