.jpg)
TV is often saturated with archetypes, neatly packaged figures designed for easy consumption. But every so often, a series introduces characters who defy those tidy boxes, exploding onto the screen with a force that shatters preconceived notions and irrevocably alters the narrative of power. Today, my thoughts gravitate towards two such monumental figures, complex, formidable, and utterly captivating women who, for me, redefined what it means to be a “power woman” on television: Olivia Pope from Scandal and Annalise Keating from How to Get Away with Murder.
These weren’t just characters; they were forces of nature, navigating treacherous landscapes of politics, law, and personal demons with a blend of brilliant intellect, ruthless pragmatism, and profound vulnerability. Created by Shonda Rhimes (a genius I’ve long admired, who also brought us Grey’s Anatomy‘s addictive chaos), these women weren’t just breaking glass ceilings; they were obliterating them with a gladiatorial roar, showing us that power, especially female power, is messy, complicated, and utterly compelling.
Olivia Pope: The Fixer, The Idealist, The Gladiator in a White Hat
When Scandal premiered in 2012, it introduced us to Olivia Pope (Kerry Washington), a former White House Communications Director who leaves to start her own crisis management firm, Olivia Pope & Associates. Her mantra: “I’m a fixer.” But Olivia was far more than that. She was a brilliant political operative, a master strategist, and a woman who commanded every room she walked into, often with a simple, piercing gaze.
- Unflappable Professionalism & Moral Ambiguity: Olivia was initially presented as a woman in a “white hat,” the ultimate ethical fixer. She handled unimaginable scandals for Washington’s elite with unparalleled discretion and efficiency. But as the series progressed, her white hat became increasingly stained by the murky realities of power. She made morally compromising choices, engaged in ruthless manipulations, and delved into a complex, often toxic, affair with the President of the United States. This embrace of moral ambiguity was radical; she wasn’t just a good guy, she was a complex woman navigating immense pressure.
- Master of the “Walk and Talk” (and the Whisper): Like The West Wing (a series I deeply admire for its dialogue), Scandal perfected the “walk and talk,” but infused it with a high-octane urgency. Olivia delivered rapid-fire dialogue, intricate plans, and cutting truths with a breathtaking pace. She commanded with a whisper and a stare as much as a shout.
- Vulnerability in Power: Despite her impenetrable exterior, Olivia was deeply vulnerable, grappling with childhood trauma, her complex relationship with her spy father (Rowan/Eli Pope, a truly iconic villain), and her tumultuous love life. The show fearlessly depicted her breakdowns, her addictions, and her internal struggles, proving that immense power doesn’t negate profound personal pain. This raw vulnerability humanized her in a way that defied the traditional “strong female character” trope, which often implies emotional invulnerability.
- Redefining the Professional Woman: Olivia was Black, powerful, and at the absolute top of her field, navigating a predominantly white, male-dominated world with unwavering confidence and intellect. She didn’t have to sacrifice her femininity for power; she wielded both with unapologetic force. This representation was groundbreaking and profoundly inspiring.
Olivia Pope proved that power could be complex, often dirty, and profoundly human, captivating audiences with her unwavering resolve and her constant dance on the edge of morality.
Annalise Keating: The Unapologetic Anti-Heroine of Law and Chaos
If Olivia Pope was a powerful force in a white hat (however stained), Annalise Keating (Viola Davis), from How to Get Away with Murder (premiering in 2014), was a force of nature draped in a dark, complex, and utterly mesmerizing shadow. She was a brilliant, ruthless, criminal defense attorney and law professor, whose life was a constant maelstrom of murder, deception, and psychological torment.
- Flawed Anti-Heroine Par Excellence: Annalise was not designed to be likable. She was an alcoholic, manipulative, deeply traumatized, and often cruel, yet profoundly brilliant. The show unflinchingly portrayed her addiction, her mental health struggles, and the layers of trauma that shaped her. This radical commitment to her flaws, her messy humanity, made her compelling in a way that few female protagonists had achieved. She was a raw nerve, a constant source of unpredictable atmospheric pressure.
- Viola Davis’s Transformative Performance: Viola Davis’s portrayal of Annalise Keating is, quite simply, a masterclass in acting. She delivered a performance of astonishing depth, embodying Annalise’s brilliance, her rage, her vulnerability, and her profound pain with unparalleled force. Her ability to strip away makeup and wigs in raw, vulnerable scenes became iconic, symbolizing Annalise’s relentless search for truth beneath the facades. Davis won an Emmy for this role, the first Black woman to win Outstanding Lead Actress in a Drama Series.
- Power in Vulnerability: Annalise derived her power not from being perfect, but from embracing her own messy, traumatized truth. She was strongest when she was most vulnerable, when she shed her carefully constructed defenses and exposed her raw humanity. She showed that true strength isn’t about being invulnerable, but about surviving immense pain and continuing to fight.
- Unconventional Mentorship: Annalise’s relationship with her students (the “Keating Five”) was deeply unhealthy and manipulative, yet also, paradoxically, a form of twisted mentorship, pushing them to excel under extreme pressure. She taught them how to “get away with murder” while implicitly exposing the systemic injustices of the legal system.
- Queer Identity and Fluidity: Annalise’s sexuality was explored with a refreshing fluidity, featuring profound relationships with both men and women. Her bisexuality was integral to her character, not a tokenistic addition, showcasing a more complex and realistic portrayal of identity.
Redefining the Trope: Beyond the Perfect Performance
Olivia Pope and Annalise Keating didn’t just redefine the “power woman” trope; they fundamentally dismantled it. They moved beyond the idea that a powerful woman must be perfect, infallible, or emotionally impenetrable. Instead, they showed that immense power can coexist with:
- Profound Flaws: They were complex, often contradictory, and deeply human, making terrible decisions and suffering immense consequences.
- Messy Personal Lives: Their professional brilliance was often contrasted with chaotic, unhealthy personal lives, reflecting the often-unseen sacrifices and challenges of those who achieve immense power.
- Raw Vulnerability: They were unafraid to show their pain, their struggles, their addictions, and their deepest insecurities, humanizing their power and making them incredibly relatable.
- Moral Ambiguity: They operated in shades of gray, making choices that challenged conventional morality but were often rooted in profound loyalty, love, or a distorted sense of justice.
- Unapologetic Ambition: They fiercely pursued power, not always for altruistic reasons, but because they believed they could wield it effectively, or simply because they craved it.
These characters fundamentally reshaped the landscape of television drama, ushering in an era where female power is depicted not as a sanitized ideal, but as a messy, complicated, often brutal, and profoundly compelling reality. They dared to explore the full spectrum of what it means to be powerful, intelligent, and deeply human, inspiring a generation of complex female protagonists who are not afraid to be both brilliant and broken. Their radiance continues to illuminate the entertainment firmament, reminding us that true strength often lies in embracing all the complex, contradictory currents of one’s being.
What other female characters do you believe have redefined tropes in powerful ways? What aspects of Olivia Pope or Annalise Keating resonated most deeply with you? Share your thoughts below – let’s dissect the art of complex character development!